Uncategorized

Post-Post Modernism: The Color-Constructed Truth Model

I like to be on the cutting-edge of things.  To be an effective leader, one must understand the trends of today and follow them through to see what these trends might look like 10 years from now and then again see things 100 years from now.  An effective leader will consider how their practices will guide their students ten years from now.  With this preface, I ask the question, “What is coming after postmodernism?”

First, a brief look at postmodernism.  The philosophy of postmodernism deals with the complex issue of language.  Philosphers for the last few hundred years have begun looking at how prior knowledge affects our reading of the materials in front of us.  Theorists began noticing that the way we interpret texts seems very bound up in the way that we understand the world.  We all come with our particular bias to a document and they suggested that we must admit this bias.  As a result, others took this theory to the point of postmodernism which suggests that truth largely eludes us.  We can’t know truth because each of us constructs our truth around us in an individual way.

This is postmodernism in a nutshell.  What is coming next?  We must first consider the virtually unlimited capacity of the internet and social networking and the effect that it will have on education.  Watch this video:

Now consider what implications the video has for education.  Postmodernism, the idea that truth is elusive and every person must construct their own truth, will inevitably be replaced by what I refer to as color-constructed truth.  I can only explain this by way of example.  In the future, my projection is that all work will be done online.  A student might write an essay and then each person will comment on that essay using new programs like textflow.  Program like textflow allow each person to comment on a document created and then to be sent back to the original author.  The author can then choose to include or reject these comments in their papers.  If you think of each of these comments as additions or subtractions from a paper and think of each other author as a color, you find that each person’s truth is constructed within community with each color a part of that student’s work.

I project work will be done within this color-constructed truth model within fifteen to twenty years.  Wiki’s are the beginning of this technology, and more evolved wiki’s will be created within two to three years that allow students to edit one another’s work cross-continentally in real time.  Indeed, the beta programs have already come out for many of these programs.  For instance, in my high school science classes we conducted experiments, wrote up our findings in a quadrille notebook, and turned them in for a grade.  A simple entry might have an hypothesis, a discussion of the experiment and the steps within the experiment, the data, and then the outcome.  In a color-constructed truth model, a teacher would input their hypothesis into a wiki database, and then students, using their color and IP address, would input information adding to the hypothesis or beginning new paragraphs where they disagree with or insert a qualifier.  Students are required to make the hypothesis paragraph flow together.  They are required to construct the hypothesis together and to edit it together until they have come to a democratic decision.  Students maintian some individuality in this process, but their thoughts are absorbed into the classroom community.

In the same way, analyzing the results of data used to be graphed in a quadrille notebook and analyzed for patterns, but in today’s wiki world, the same data can be entered in a classroom data table in real time and analyzed statistically for variations and outliers.  Statistics will be the new mothermath in this new color-constructed truth model.  The theoretical maths will still have a major place to help us make sense of the statistics, but statistics that used to be impossibly large are becoming quite manageable in a world with unlimited amounts of data.  It is possible to have a district at all the high schools do the same experiment and to put all the data from the experiment into one wiki where the data can be analyzed on a meta-level.  These types of meta-level analyses will become more normal in research at the graduate level and will also trickle down to high school and elementary education.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Post-Post Modernism: The Color-Constructed Truth Model

  1. Hey, Dan…fromthe education perspective.
    1) After 20+ years of math, I can say that I hate statistics. Its probably the least satisfying branch; I always thought physiscists would one day hope to do without it and solve the paradox of the uncertainty principle.

    2) One of the things I use a lot, which drives me to participate in education type discussions is this bit from Christina Hoff Summers:

    On a recent “Jay-walking” interview segment, Jay Leno asked young people about the Bible. “Can you name one of the Ten Commandments?” he asked two college-age women. One replied, “Freedom of speech?” Leno said to the other, “Complete this sentence: Let he who is without sin…” Her reply: “have a good time?” Leno asked a young man, “Who, according to the Bible, was eaten by a whale?” “Pinocchio” was the confident reply.

    “When you have as many conversations with young people as I do, you come away both exhilarated and depressed. In many ways they are more likeable than the baby boomers—they are less fascinated with themselves and more able to laugh at their faults. An astonishing number do volunteer work.

    “Conceptually and culturally, however, today’s young people live in a moral haze. Ask one of them if there are such things as ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ and suddenly you are confronted with a confused, tongue-tied, nervous and insecure individual. ‘It’s kind of like whatever works best for the individual. Each person has to work it out for himself.’”
    —Christina Hoff Sommers

    “Ask one of them if there are such things as ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ and suddenly you are confronted with a confused, tongue-tied, nervous and insecure individual.”

    And compare that to this:

    “What is the glue that keeps so many different individuals bound together? It is not a common ancestry, a single religion, a privileged aristocracy, a rigid caste system or the force of arms. It is a shared set of ideas about liberty, rights, responsibilities, equality, and the rule of law. It is a desire to get ahead and in the words of Lincoln, ‘improve one’s lot in life.’

    It is a shared sense of optimism that people can solve their own problems and overcome great obstacles without having to result to force or create a huge bureaucracy.

    Finally, it is a shared spirit of generosity and charity that makes the Golden Rule a fundamental part of the American creed.

    We’ve been doing color constructed truth for 5000 years now. The results are what we should be teaching in school.

  2. Ed,
    Thanks for these quotes. I think what you are saying is very important. I am no mathematician, but I actually find statistics the most interesting. This is probably because I come from a history perspective and will hopefully be entering into a history classroom starting in the 09-10 school year.

    Nate,
    It is a brave new world indeed. It is funny that some of the things in science fiction books may soon become part of the real world. We do have some major things to consider within this realm.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s